Informal poll-Stick or Auto?

No tech discussion, please

Moderator: FORDification

Post Reply
the elder rocker
New Member
New Member
Posts: 48
Joined: Tue Sep 05, 2017 3:54 pm

Informal poll-Stick or Auto?

Post by the elder rocker »

Hi Folks-
New at this F100 thing. I have 2 '67s. 1 SWB Custom cab that's a 390 with a granny low 4 speed. The other is a Ranger parts truck with a 352 and an automatic. I could go either way here. Which is best? I prefer the stick shift, but I'm getting older and crotchety. I also learned to drive in a stick shift car. A stick shift is also somewhat of a theft deterrant nowadays. It's like the old "never trust a motorcycle you can't kick start" thing! Which is more desireable in the Ford truck world? You guys are the gurus, lay out some of that sweet, sweet Fordophile knowledge!
Thanks ahead!
Mike
User avatar
farmallmta
New Member
New Member
Posts: 143
Joined: Sat Nov 16, 2013 2:00 pm

Stick! More fun, better mileage, better driver JMHO

Post by farmallmta »

NM
Ohiotinkerer
Blue Oval Fanatic
Blue Oval Fanatic
Posts: 852
Joined: Wed Nov 09, 2016 5:49 pm
Location: Galion, Ohio

Re: Informal poll-Stick or Auto?

Post by Ohiotinkerer »

My preference is manual - some people think I'm dumb but I would rather replace a $100 clutch than a $1000+ rebuild of an automatic.......and a lot less things to go wrong with a manual.......as well as the theft issue - car thieves nowadays will pass up a stick shift because they never drove one.......


And I love to shift thru the gears......... :D
"Life is a garden - dig it"........... :thup:

1968 F100 2wd - Rangoon Red - 360 w/T18 - power steering and brakes
1997 Honda CBR 900RR
User avatar
Canonman67
Blue Oval Fan
Blue Oval Fan
Posts: 536
Joined: Wed Apr 30, 2014 4:49 pm
Location: California, Galt

Re: Informal poll-Stick or Auto?

Post by Canonman67 »

Manual for me. It's also easier to get an overdrive with a manual.
71Fe2O3
New Member
New Member
Posts: 137
Joined: Fri Mar 24, 2017 8:26 pm
Location: CT

Re: Informal poll-Stick or Auto?

Post by 71Fe2O3 »

My preference is for manual. My trucks and my modern daily driver are manuals. When I began driving, automatic transmissions were not as durable as manuals, and, as Ohiotinkerer said, manual was less expensive to operate. Modern automatics are much better, and I suspect the maintenance has flipped the other way, with clutches wearing out long before automatics need to be overhauled. I still prefer working through the gears, the feeling of control, and using both arms and legs to drive. One of my trucks has three-on-the-tree, which I find very cool because I learned to drive on one, and because they are now obsolete.
Fred

1970 F100 4WD short bed, 360 engine, very rusty plow and yard truck

1971 F100 2WD long bed, 302 engine, on the road

1968 F100 2WD long bed, 360 engine, stripping for parts
User avatar
sargentrs
100% FORDified!
100% FORDified!
Posts: 9866
Joined: Fri Jun 22, 2007 9:30 am
Location: Georgia, Jasper

Re: Informal poll-Stick or Auto?

Post by sargentrs »

:yt: Also a lot of options for swapping in a different transmission. Just something about that lunge forward as your foot leaves the clutch that gives me a cheap thrill. 8)
Randy
1970 F100 Sport Custom Limited LWB, 302cid, 3 on the tree. NO A/C, NO P/S, NO P/B. Currently in 1000 pcs while rebuilding. Project thread: http://www.fordification.com/forum/view ... 22&t=59995 Plan: 351w, C4, LSD, pwr front disc, p/s, a/c, bucket seats, new interior and paint.
1987 F-150 XLT Lariat, 5.0/C6 auto.
User avatar
1972hiboy
100% FORDified!
100% FORDified!
Posts: 2421
Joined: Thu Sep 09, 2010 5:44 pm
Location: California, Santa Cruz

Re: Informal poll-Stick or Auto?

Post by 1972hiboy »

I think it depends on what kind of driving your doing most of. I have always been a conventional four-speed kind of guy, but the driving situation here in Cali make it to where sitting in literally stop,wait,then creep, then stop again traffic has made the four speed a pain in the left knee. Constant pumping is no fun. If your in a open area or town where traffic isn't a reality, then four speed driving would still be fun. But these days, in my part of the country a C6 is a welcome sight for everyday use. :2cents:
Rich
1973 f350 super c/s 460/c6 22k orig miles
1972 f350 srw crewcab special 390
1972 f250 4x4 sport custom 390fe Red
1972 f250 4x4 custom 360 FE " Ranger Ric"
1972 f250 4x4 custom 84k og miles 390
1971 f250 4x4 sport custom 56k og miles. 360
1970 f250 4x4 428 fe hp60 205 d60
Dont eat yellow snow.....
User avatar
colnago
100% FORDified!
100% FORDified!
Posts: 1882
Joined: Tue Jun 14, 2011 8:48 pm
Location: Ridgecrest, CA

Re: Informal poll-Stick or Auto?

Post by colnago »

I guess I'll buck the trend and say auto. I have a C6 in my '67 (it originally came with a Cruise-o-Matic, but it turned into a C6 somewhere in its 50-year history), and never felt the need to convert it. If I'm in stop-and-go traffic, I want an auto. If I'm in hill country with traffic, I definitely want auto (I had to do San Francisco once, driving my folks' '68 Dodge van with 3-on-the-tree; what a PITA that was). If I'm just cruising, there's no benefit to a manual. If the truck came with a manual, I would have kept it, but I don't feel the need for manual.

Now, if I ever get a sports car, it will have to have a manual, because that's half the fun! Zoom-zoom!

Just my :2cents:

Joseph
"Sugar", my 1967 Ford F250 2WD Camper Special, 352FE, Ford iron "T" Intake with 1405 Edelbrock, Duraspark II Ignition, C6 transmission, front disc brake conversion.
tnlprt
Blue Oval Guru
Blue Oval Guru
Posts: 1144
Joined: Thu Jul 08, 2010 5:18 pm
Location: St Louis mo

Re: Informal poll-Stick or Auto?

Post by tnlprt »

Dare to be different

Reverse manual valve body C6 with a ratchet shifter

I have to physically shift it into each and every gear
User avatar
popeyes71
Blue Oval Guru
Blue Oval Guru
Posts: 1176
Joined: Tue Jan 31, 2012 3:46 pm
Location: Bay Area, Ca.

Re: Informal poll-Stick or Auto?

Post by popeyes71 »

I would have to agree with 1972hiboy. I love having a manual in my Highboy but I hate driving the truck in traffic. My leg starts getting tired quick from pushing the clutch in and out in the stop and go traffic. But when I'm cruising the back roads or playing with the truck off-road; the manual is king! So to me, it really depends on the kind of driving you plan on doing with your truck.
-Popeye-
1971 F-250 4x4 Highboy
1966 Chevy Nova, 8 second 10.5 car
Lee
New Member
New Member
Posts: 215
Joined: Sat Nov 27, 2004 10:04 am
Location: Lacey, Washington

Re: Informal poll-Stick or Auto?

Post by Lee »

Well,... since my truck has 3 shifters,.... it's MANUAL for me.

1st shifter = 2-speed Ranger Torque Splitter
2nd shifter = NP-435 four speed.
3rd shifter = NP205 transfer case.

:D

Lee
tsherry
Preferred User
Preferred User
Posts: 487
Joined: Fri Dec 23, 2005 11:26 pm
Location: Washington, Spokane

Re: Informal poll-Stick or Auto?

Post by tsherry »

Answer is, "depends."

Autos are more drivable in stop and go traffic. My left knee appreciates that....a lot.

Manuals though, are more fun and you can work the Hell out of them.

If I could find a way to afford to put a 2016 Ecoboost 3.5 6 speed in my '67 F-250 (390 4sp) I'd be all over it.
too many Fords, no where near 'nuff time.

or, money.
User avatar
KRob
New Member
New Member
Posts: 238
Joined: Fri Jul 15, 2011 12:05 pm
Location: Oregon, North Eastern Corner

Re: Informal poll-Stick or Auto?

Post by KRob »

Pretty much the same as everyone else. I prefer a manual for work and normal driving, however i find myself in traffic more and more and thus the automatics are looking better and better.
71 F250 4x4, 4BT Cummins Mostly Done...Project Thread http://www.fordification.com/forum/view ... 22&t=65450
(4BT, big block ZF5, 78 NP205, 78 Dana 44 Front axle, 4.10, 265/75/16, power steering, power brakes)
01 Dodge 2500 4x4 Cummins...turned up a little.
XABN82
New Member
New Member
Posts: 119
Joined: Sat Nov 05, 2011 9:52 am
Location: Chattanooga,TN

Re: Informal poll-Stick or Auto?

Post by XABN82 »

I prefer manual, but definitely a 5 speed
User avatar
Mancar1
100% FORDified!
100% FORDified!
Posts: 5390
Joined: Thu Jun 10, 2010 8:13 am
Location: USS Gramps Garage (DD-727) Tehama County, Northern Ca.

Re: Informal poll-Stick or Auto?

Post by Mancar1 »

I used to prefer a manual, but I am older now, 68 yrs young, and I now prefer a A/T.
Bottom line is it is your choice not anyone else.
I know all about older, lol :wink:
I keep getting older, and I keep on Trucking............John
May your sails stay full, and your knots not slip. Unless a slip knot.
Once I thought I was wrong, but I was wrong.
Life is a banquet, and every days a feast.
68 F-250 CS 390 C-6 P/S A/C front disc. 2nd owner.
2016 GMC Terrain Denali 301 HP V-6 AWD.
2009 Silverado Crew Cab, V-8, 4X4.
DD-727
DD-806
AE-35
LSD-39
AS-41
AR-8
Post Reply